Buffalo · NY · Vetted Directory

Top Personal Injury Lawyers in Buffalo

You were in a crash on the 33. You slipped on black ice in a parking lot in Cheektowaga. You fell off a scaffold on a downtown jobsite. A dog bit your kid on the West Side. Buffalo personal injury cases turn on three things — NY's no-fault rules, the very short notice deadlines for claims against the city and the NFTA, and the lawyer's experience with whichever specific type of accident you had. Below are vetted Buffalo firms that take these cases on contingency. You pay nothing up front, and nothing if you lose. The clock starts the day of the accident, and the deadlines for public defendants run very short.

5
Vetted Firms
★ 4.9
Avg Rating
$0
No Win, No Fee
3 years
NY PI Statute

When you need a Buffalo personal injury lawyer

Most Buffalo accident cases benefit from a lawyer the same week the accident happens, even if the injury seems minor at the time. Soft-tissue injuries get worse over weeks. Insurance adjusters call early, when you are vulnerable, and try to lock in low statements. NY's no-fault rules require prompt filing of PIP within 30 days. Public defendants (City of Buffalo, NFTA, Erie County, NYS) require a Notice of Claim within 90 days — miss it and the case may be over before it starts.

Call a Buffalo PI lawyer if any of the following applies.

  • You were in a car, truck, motorcycle, rideshare, bicycle, or pedestrian crash with any injury, however minor it seems initially.
  • You slipped and fell on ice, snow, water, or a defective surface at a Buffalo property and were hurt — especially if you took medical care.
  • You were hurt at a construction site (fall, falling object, scaffolding collapse, struck by equipment) — NY Labor Law 240 and 241 may apply.
  • You were bitten by a dog in Erie County and the owner had prior knowledge of vicious tendencies, or you incurred medical costs (strict liability for medical regardless).
  • You believe you were the victim of medical malpractice at a Buffalo hospital — ECMC, Buffalo General, Sisters of Charity, Roswell Park, Millard Fillmore, Mercy.
  • A family member died because of someone else's negligence — wrongful death has a two-year statute.
  • A nursing home neglected, mistreated, or caused injury to a relative.
  • A defective product (vehicle, machinery, consumer product, drug, medical device) injured you or a family member.
  • You were over-served at a bar and the bar continued serving you (or someone else) leading to a crash — NY's dram shop law applies.

What this typically costs in Buffalo

$0
Up-front cost
33⅓%
Standard NY contingency
Sliding
Med-mal under Judiciary Law 474-a
$0
If you lose

Buffalo personal injury lawyers work on contingency — the standard fee on auto, slip and fall, dog bite, construction, and most general negligence cases is 33⅓ percent. Medical malpractice uses a sliding scale set by NY Judiciary Law 474-a: 30 percent of the first $250K, 25 percent of the next $250K, 20 percent of the next $500K, 15 percent of the next $250K, 10 percent above $1.25M. Case expenses (filing fees, expert costs, medical records) come out of the recovery, usually after the contingency. Read the retainer so you understand whether expenses are calculated before or after the fee.

How long a Buffalo personal injury case takes

  • Settlement-only auto cases: 6 to 14 months when liability is clear and injuries are documented.
  • Disputed auto cases / no-fault threshold disputes: 12 to 24 months.
  • Slip and fall (Buffalo / Erie County premises): 14 to 28 months given the snow-and-ice doctrine complexity.
  • Construction Labor Law 240/241: 18 to 36 months from filing to trial or settlement.
  • Medical malpractice in NY State Supreme Court (Erie County): 24 to 48 months. Slow but high-value when liability holds.
  • Claims against the City of Buffalo, NFTA, NYS, Erie County: Notice of Claim within 90 days, then 1 year and 90 days to sue.

Buffalo firms that handle personal injury

1

Lipsitz Green Scime Cambria

★★★★★ 4.9/5 Contingency Best Lawyers — Top Listed Buffalo PI

Named "Top Listed in Buffalo, NY in Personal Injury Litigation" by Best Lawyers — meaning no firm has more personal injury attorneys recognized in Best Lawyers in America in Buffalo than Lipsitz Green. Verdicts and settlements include a $50M recovery for the family of a mother killed in an auto collision and a $25M recovery for a driver severely injured by a liquid nitrogen tank rupture. The right fit when the case is significant.

Free Consultation Best Lawyers Top Listed $50M / $25M Verdicts Buffalo
2

Dietrich Law Firm P.C.

★★★★★ 4.9/5 Contingency (33⅓%) $175M+ Recovered Since 1999

Buffalo personal injury firm established in 2005 by Joseph "Jed" Dietrich. Has recovered more than $175 million on behalf of injury victims since 1999. Practice covers auto crashes, truck crashes, motorcycle, construction, slip and fall, and wrongful death across Buffalo and Western NY. Phone: 716-839-3939. Strong on early case-development work — getting the insurance picture, the medical baseline, and the witness statements locked in fast.

Free Consultation $175M+ Recovered Est. 2005 📞 716-839-3939
3

O'Brien & Ford, P.C.

★★★★★ 4.8/5 Contingency $100M+ Recovered · 80+ Years

Buffalo personal injury firm that has recovered over $100 million for clients across 80-plus years of combined firm experience. Plaintiff-side practice covering auto crashes, premises liability, construction, medical malpractice, and wrongful death. Smaller-firm feel with the trial experience of a much larger shop. Good fit when you want senior attorney attention without a megafirm marketing budget passed through to your file.

Free Consultation $100M+ Recovered 80+ Yrs Combined Buffalo
4

Andrews, Bernstein & Maranto, PLLC

★★★★★ 4.8/5 Contingency Auto / Slip-Fall / Construction Focus

Buffalo firm established in 1999, focused exclusively on representing injured plaintiffs. Practice areas: motor vehicle accidents, slip and fall, dog bites, and construction accidents. Eight personal injury lawyers plus support staff. Useful when you want a firm that does plaintiff PI only — no insurance defense, no commercial work, no conflicts.

Free Consultation Plaintiff Only Est. 1999 8 PI Attorneys
5

Hutcheson, Affronti & Deisinger, P.C.

★★★★★ 4.7/5 Contingency State + Federal Court Practice

Represents Buffalo personal injury victims in both state and federal courts throughout NY. Practice covers auto crashes, defective products, medical malpractice, and slip and fall cases. Good fit when the case crosses jurisdictional lines — diversity-of-citizenship federal court matters, federal product liability, or claims against federal facilities and contractors.

Free Consultation State + Federal Courts Product Liability Med-Mal

Talk to a Buffalo personal injury lawyer — free.

Tell us briefly what happened. We route a confidential request to the best-fit Buffalo firm in this directory. No fee unless you win.

Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. Do not send confidential medical or insurance records until you have signed an engagement letter.

Personal Injury in Buffalo — FAQ

What does a Buffalo personal injury lawyer cost?
Contingency. Standard 33⅓% for auto and most negligence. Med-mal uses sliding scale under Judiciary Law 474-a. $0 if you lose.
What's the deadline to sue?
3 years for general PI, 2½ years for med-mal, 2 years for wrongful death. Claims against city/NFTA/state need a 90-day Notice of Claim and lawsuit within 1 year 90 days.
How does NY no-fault work?
Your own PIP pays up to $50K regardless of fault. To sue the at-fault driver for pain and suffering, you must meet NY's serious injury threshold under Insurance Law 5102(d).
Hurt on a construction site?
Labor Law 240 (Scaffold Law) imposes strict liability for gravity-related falls. Labor Law 241(6) requires Industrial Code compliance. Workers comp claim runs in parallel.
What kinds of cases do Buffalo PI lawyers handle?
Auto, truck, motorcycle, rideshare, slip/fall (ice and snow heavy), dog bite, Labor Law 240/241 construction, med-mal, nursing home, dram shop, product liability, wrongful death.
What's a slip-and-fall worth in Buffalo?
Variable — storm-in-progress doctrine often protects owners during active snow. Old accumulation, defective drainage, or notice of hazard usually win. Ranges $5K–$1M+ depending on injury.
What about wrongful death?
NY focuses on pecuniary loss (financial support, services, guidance) rather than emotional grief. Survival action recovers pre-death pain and suffering. 2-year statute is short — move quickly.

Related on LawFirmSquare