Buffalo · NY · Vetted Directory

Top Disability Lawyers in Buffalo

You stopped being able to work and you applied for Social Security Disability. Maybe you got the first denial. Maybe you're staring at the reconsideration denial and looking at an 18-month wait for a hearing in front of an ALJ at the Buffalo Office of Hearings Operations on South Elmwood Avenue. The good news: Buffalo SSDI lawyers all work on contingency capped at 25% of back pay or $7,200, whichever is lower — there is no out-of-pocket cost, and you pay nothing if you lose. Hearing-level approval rates with representation in Buffalo run above 60 percent. Below are vetted firms.

5
Vetted Firms
$0
Upfront cost
25% / $7,200
Fee cap
~60%
ALJ win rate w/ rep

When you need a Buffalo SSDI / SSI lawyer

Most claimants try the initial application alone. About a third of them are approved. The other two-thirds end up at reconsideration, which has its own denial rate of roughly 85 percent, and then face the question of whether to give up or request a hearing. The hearing in front of an ALJ at the Buffalo ODAR is where most Buffalo cases are won — and where having representation makes the biggest statistical difference. Bringing a lawyer in at the application stage helps. Bringing one in by the reconsideration stage at the latest is what most Buffalo disability attorneys would tell you.

Call a Buffalo disability lawyer if any of the following describes where you are.

  • You stopped being able to work due to a physical or mental condition expected to last at least 12 months or to be terminal.
  • Your initial SSDI or SSI application was denied and you are still within the 60-day window to appeal.
  • You were denied at reconsideration and need to request a hearing before an ALJ at the Buffalo ODAR.
  • You have a hearing date scheduled and want representation before you walk in.
  • You won SSDI but your benefits were terminated after a Continuing Disability Review.
  • You are unsure whether to file for SSDI, SSI, or both, given your work history and current income.
  • You are receiving long-term disability insurance and the carrier is pressuring you to file for SSDI to offset their payments.
  • You have multiple impairments — physical and mental — that individually might not qualify but in combination prevent you from working.
  • You are over 50 and were forced out of a physical job by injury or illness (the Medical-Vocational Grid rules favor older claimants).

SSDI vs. SSI — the short version

SSDI (Title II) is the insurance program. You qualify if you worked long enough and recently enough — usually 5 of the last 10 years — paying Social Security taxes. Benefit amount depends on your earnings history, averaging about $1,580/month in 2025. SSI (Title XVI) is the needs-based program for disabled people with little income and few resources. Max SSI is $967/month for an individual in 2025, less if you have any other income. The medical disability standard is the same for both. Many Buffalo claimants qualify for both — "concurrent" claims — and the lawyer evaluates which to push hardest based on your work credits and financial picture.

What this typically costs in Buffalo

$0
Upfront cost
25%
Of back pay
$7,200
Absolute fee cap
$0
If you lose

Social Security disability representation in Buffalo is a flat federal regime: 25% of past-due benefits, with an absolute cap currently set at $7,200. Nothing up front, nothing if you lose. SSA withholds the fee from your back pay and sends it to the attorney directly — you do not write a check. Out-of-pocket costs are modest: medical record copying fees ($25 to $200 total), possibly a treating physician's report ($150 to $400). Some Buffalo firms front these expenses and recover them only on a win.

How long the Buffalo SSDI process takes

  • Initial application: 4 to 8 months for a decision from NY Disability Determination Services.
  • Reconsideration (if denied): 4 to 6 additional months.
  • Hearing request to actual hearing date at Buffalo ODAR: 9 to 12 months (improved from peak pandemic-era backlogs of 18+ months).
  • Decision after hearing: 1 to 3 months from the hearing date.
  • Appeals Council review (if hearing denied): 12 to 24 months.
  • Federal district court appeal in WDNY: 9 to 18 months.

Buffalo firms that handle disability

1

William C. Bernhardi Law Offices, PLLC

★★★★★ 4.9/5 Contingency 25% / $7,200 cap Buffalo Area SSD Focus

Elma-based practice focused exclusively on Social Security Disability and SSI for clients in the greater Buffalo area. Solo-driven firm where the attorney handles the hearing in front of the ALJ — not a paralegal who walks in cold the morning of. Good fit for clients who want a single point of contact through the years-long process from initial denial to award.

Free Consultation SSD + SSI Only 📍 Elma Attorney at Hearing
2

MCV Law

★★★★★ 4.8/5 Contingency 25% / $7,200 cap 30+ Years NY SSD

Upstate NY disability practice with more than 30 years of Social Security work and a Buffalo-area presence. Walks claimants through the entire process from initial application through ALJ hearing and Appeals Council if needed. Good fit for claimants who feel intimidated by the SSA paperwork and want to be talked through each step in plain English.

Free Consultation 30+ Years SSD Application → Appeal Upstate NY
3

The Steenberg Law Firm

★★★★★ 4.7/5 Contingency 25% / $7,200 cap Application Through ALJ

Buffalo SSD practice handling claims from initial application through hearing-level appeals. Files the request for a hearing in front of an ALJ, prepares the client for testimony, handles vocational expert cross-examination at the hearing, and prosecutes the case through the Buffalo ODAR. Good fit for a denied initial application that needs aggressive appeal management.

Free Consultation ALJ Hearings Appeals Focus Buffalo
4

Connors & Ferris

★★★★★ 4.7/5 Contingency 25% / $7,200 cap SSD + Workers' Comp

Buffalo-area firm with a Social Security Disability and workers' compensation practice. Strong fit when the disability claim is connected to a work injury — both the SSDI claim and the WCB Section 32 settlement can be coordinated so the offset is structured to maximize the claimant's overall recovery rather than each system pulling against the other.

Free Consultation SSD + WC Coordination Buffalo (716) 684-COMP
5

The Antonowicz Group

★★★★★ 4.6/5 Contingency 25% / $7,200 cap Upstate NY Disability

Upstate NY disability practice serving Buffalo and Western NY claimants from a base in Utica. Files SSDI and SSI applications and handles appeals through the Buffalo ODAR. Good fit for clients in the eastern WNY counties or with a connection to Utica/Mohawk Valley who want one firm covering the regional ALJ rosters.

Free Consultation SSD + SSI Upstate NY App + Appeals

Talk to a Buffalo disability lawyer — free.

Tell us briefly where you are in the process. We route a confidential request to the best-fit Buffalo firm in this directory.

Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. Do not send confidential documents until you have signed an engagement letter.

Disability in Buffalo — FAQ

What does a Buffalo SSDI lawyer cost?
$0 upfront, $0 if you lose. Federal cap: 25% of back pay or $7,200, whichever is lower. SSA withholds the fee from back pay and pays the attorney directly.
Where are Buffalo hearings held?
SSA Office of Hearings Operations, 130 South Elmwood Avenue, Suite 400, Buffalo. Many hearings now held by video or phone.
SSDI or SSI?
SSDI: insurance program — need 5 of last 10 years of work. Avg $1,580/mo. SSI: needs-based — max $967/mo (2025). Many qualify for both ("concurrent" claim).
How long does Buffalo SSDI take?
Initial: 4–8 months. Recon: 4–6 more months. Hearing wait: 9–12 months. Decision: 1–3 months. Total to favorable hearing: 18–30 months.
My claim was denied. Now what?
60 days to request reconsideration. Most cases are won at hearing, not at initial. Don't miss deadlines.
What conditions qualify?
No automatic-approval list. Listings (Blue Book) cover major conditions. Most win on residual functional capacity (RFC) — can't do past work or any other work given age, education, skills.
How much back pay?
SSDI back pay runs from established onset (with 5-month waiting period) to decision. Long hearing waits can produce $30K–$60K+ lump sums.
Can I work while waiting?
Limited only. Over substantial gainful activity ($1,550/mo in 2025) will deny the claim. Always talk to the attorney before taking work.

Related on LawFirmSquare